The descriptions of items where a title is not stated are taken from the Digital Index of Middle English Verse entry. The British Library catalogue record has a slightly different set of names for the items.
The descriptions of items where a title is not stated are taken from the Digital Index of Middle English Verse entry. The British Library catalogue record has a slightly different set of names for the items.
The claims that this manuscript is collated by Robert S. Kinsman, but there is no indication that the article it sites, "A Lamentable of Kyng Edward the IIII," has done so. Kinsman's focus is on the poem and so the work is primarily interested in the study of sigla for the poem in question. I can only assume that when CELM refers to the "collation" they are referring to Kinsman's work charting the relationship between the witnesses. The manuscript itself is also not much help, as it has been trimmed such that any reference to quire markers or catchwords are missing save for the verso of folio 132, where "callid þe well" appears on the lower right corner. Interestingly, this would be the proper place for the end of a gathering if it were gathered in six, but without any other indications that remains conjectural.
There are three blank pages in the volume at 83 verso, 86 verso, and 183 verso, but they do not fall at the end of any of the gatherings if we assume the volume is gathered in six. Interestingly, the first and last of these blank pages occur adter the volume's longest works, Lydgate's and , with the outlier being the shorter "To Henry VI on his Coronation."
The entire book is written chiefly in John Stow'ssomewhat inconsistent secretary hand, with the following features:
Stow is fairly consistent about differentiating between "u" and "v" when intended, rendering the latter with a raised initial minim that at times can almost appear like an ascender. It is tempting to assume that this is just how the scribe renders "u" in the initial position of a word, but examples like "delyver" and "servaunt" in stanza 9 of Lydgate's (the first stanza on 180v) clarify that this is a deliberate choice and that they do see the two letters as separate glyphs.
For this reason where "u" is in the initial position in a word ("us" in the , for example, in the third stanza on the same page) it has been rendered as "vs." While the scribe consistently makes the initial stroke higher when "v" rather than "u" is meant there is no similar consistent distinction between "u" and "w." An initial "w" can have a raised minim, as can be seen in some places in words like "Withynne" in the final stanza of f.180v or "With" in the first stanza of f. 181r, but it becomes more difficult to ascertain when the letter is rendered within a word, such as with "bowe." Generally, the upward stroke in the final minim of "w" hooks slightly to the left at the top, then runs into the letter following, while in "u" it tends to complete the final minim then begin the upstroke for the next letter. This can be seen clearly in "plukked" in the second stanza of f.180v and in "bowe" throughout.
In certain words, such as "our," it is not entirely clear whether the letter intended is "u" or "w" at first glance, partially because the way Stow tends to write "r" in some cases resembles the modern number 3 more than what is to modern eyes a more familar form of the letter. Comparing the formation of the final two glyphs in "our" with the formation of the final two glyphs in "merrour" (line six of the third stanza on f. 181r), "licour" (line one of the first stanza on f. 182r), and "socour" (line five of the second stanza on the same page) suggests at first that the final two glyphs in "our" throughout are actually "wr," particularly in the form it is rendered where "our" appears twice in the second line of the fourth stanza on f. 179v. When compared to "liberte" (line six of the first stanza of f. 181r) and in particular to "recoure" (line five of the same stanza), however, it is clear that the form of the "r" glyph creates the impression of a second bow. This is largely due to stow beginning the strokes for the "r" glyph from the bottom of the second minim of his "u."